A Torch Against the Night Review: A Thrilling Sequel That Shines Brighter

Does Sabaa Tahir’s Sequel Live Up to the Hype?

A Torch Against the Night, the second installment in Sabaa Tahir’s An Ember in the Ashes series, delivers an electrifying continuation of Elias and Laia’s journey. With a 4.23-star rating from over 180,000 readers on Goodreads, this 452-page novel cements Tahir’s place as a master of YA fantasy. But does it hold its own against its predecessor? Absolutely—and then some.

What Makes This Book Stand Out?

Readers consistently praise Tahir’s relentless pacing and expansive world-building. Unlike many middle books that suffer from "bridge syndrome," A Torch Against the Night escalates the stakes while deepening character arcs. The story follows Laia and Elias as they race to save Laia’s brother from Kauf Prison, pursued by the ruthless Helene Aquilla, now the Blood Shrike. Tahir masterfully balances high-stakes action with emotional depth, avoiding the common trap of prioritizing spectacle over substance.

Characters That Steal Your Heart (and Your Breath)

Goodreads reviewers overwhelmingly highlight the character development as the novel’s crowning achievement. Helene’s perspective, newly introduced here, adds fascinating layers to the conflict—her loyalty to the Empire clashes heartbreakingly with her personal bonds. Meanwhile, Laia’s transformation from fearful survivor to determined leader feels earned, not rushed. Elias’ struggle with his dual nature (both as a warrior and an empath) resonates deeply, making him one of YA’s most compelling protagonists.

A World That Feels Alive

Tahir’s Mythology-rich setting earns consistent applause. From the eerie Waiting Place to the brutal Kauf Prison, every location pulses with history and danger. The magic system—particularly the supernatural elements involving the Nightbringer—expands intriguingly without overwhelming readers. Parents and educators will appreciate how Tahir weaves themes of resistance and moral choice into the narrative, offering young readers plenty to ponder beyond the adrenaline-fueled plot.

Minor Criticisms (Because No Book Is Perfect)

Some reviewers noted the shifting perspectives (now including Helene’s POV) required brief adjustment, though most agreed this enriched the story. At 452 pages, the novel demands commitment, but Tahir’s crisp prose and short chapters maintain momentum. A handful wished for more screen time for certain side characters, but this is a testament to how invested readers become in Tahir’s ensemble.

Final Verdict: Who Should Read This?

Perfect for fans of Victoria Aveyard’s Red Queen or Marie Lu’s Legend, this sequel surpasses expectations. It’s ideal for:

• YA fantasy lovers craving complex characters amid breakneck action
• Readers who appreciate moral gray areas in their heroes and villains
• Those seeking diverse representation in fantasy without tokenism

With its heart-stopping climax and lingering questions, A Torch Against the Night ensures you’ll immediately reach for the next book. Sabaa Tahir doesn’t just carry the torch—she sets the entire genre ablaze.

Ready to dive in? Get your copy on Amazon here.