Book Review: 4:50 from Paddington by Agatha Christie

Rating: ★★★★☆ (3.97/5) | Pages: 288 | Genre: Mystery, Crime Fiction

Get the Book on Amazon

A Timeless Whodunit with Christie’s Signature Twists

Agatha Christie’s 4:50 from Paddington (also published as What Mrs. McGillicuddy Saw!) is a masterclass in suspense, blending sharp wit, meticulous plotting, and the indomitable Miss Marple. First published in 1957, this mystery remains a standout in Christie’s legendary catalog, praised for its ingenious premise and satisfying resolution.

The Plot: A Glimpse of Murder

The story kicks off with Mrs. McGillicuddy, an ordinary woman who witnesses a chilling event: from her train window, she sees a man strangling a woman in a passing carriage. With no evidence and skeptical authorities, she turns to her sharp-eyed friend, Jane Marple. Despite her unassuming demeanor, Miss Marple pieces together clues that lead to the wealthy but dysfunctional Crackenthorpe family—and a hidden corpse. What follows is a deftly woven investigation filled with red herrings, hidden motives, and Christie’s trademark surprises.

Why Readers Love It

Fans on Goodreads consistently highlight three strengths:

• Miss Marple’s Brilliance: The elderly sleuth’s quiet intelligence and psychological insight steal the show. She solves crimes from her armchair yet outsmarts professionals.
• The Crackenthorpe Family: A dysfunctional clan with secrets galore, their interactions add humor and tension.
• The Pacing: Christie balances slow-burn clues with bursts of action, keeping readers hooked.

A Few Caveats

Some reviewers note that the middle section drags slightly, and the resolution relies on a coincidence. However, most agree the payoff is worth it—a testament to Christie’s ability to tie loose ends elegantly.

Who Should Read This?

Perfect for mystery lovers who enjoy:

• Classic "cozy" mysteries with minimal violence.
• Complex puzzles where everyone’s a suspect.
• Strong, unconventional detectives (move over, Poirot!).

Final Verdict

4:50 from Paddington is Christie at her finest—clever, charming, and impossible to put down. While not her most explosive work, it’s a must-read for Marple fans and proof that the simplest observations can unravel the darkest crimes.

Rating: 4/5 | Perfect for: Rainy afternoons, train rides, or anyone craving a mystery that plays fair but keeps you guessing.

Grab your copy today and join the investigation!